Skip to content
Loading page

Started by Samuel Okafor (@samokafor) ·

what does a sprinkler do if you run it backwards

6 sources · 34 min down the hole

How I got here

Started with
If a sprinkler sucks water in instead of spraying it out, does it turn?
Ended at
“Feynman reverse sprinkler solved”

The Trail

  1. “reverse sprinkler which way does it spin” (google.com)
  2. Feynman sprinkler (en.wikipedia.org)

    feynman's attempt at princeton apparently ended with a glass jug exploding

  3. Richard Feynman (en.wikipedia.org)
  4. Ernst Mach (en.wikipedia.org)

    the question goes back to mach in the 1880s, way before feynman

  5. “nyu reverse sprinkler 2024 experiment” (google.com)
  6. “Feynman reverse sprinkler solved” (hn.algolia.com)

What I came away with

A 2024 NYU experiment with a very low-friction sprinkler found it does turn, slowly, in the opposite direction to a normal sprinkler. The answer comes down to subtle flows inside the body of the sprinkler, which is why simple momentum arguments kept giving people different answers.

Keep going