Skip to content
Loading page

Started by Henrik Larsen (@henrik_l) ·

the four color theorem was the first big proof nobody could check by hand

5 sources · 39 min down the hole

How I got here

Started with
Why was the four color theorem proof so controversial?
Ended at
Proof assistant

The Trail

  1. “four color theorem computer proof controversy” (google.com)
  2. Four color theorem (en.wikipedia.org)

    illinois put 'four colors suffice' on its postmark

  3. Computer-assisted proof (en.wikipedia.org)
  4. Kenneth Appel (en.wikipedia.org)
  5. Proof assistant (en.wikipedia.org)

What I came away with

In 1976 Appel and Haken reduced it to almost two thousand configurations and had a computer check each one, and plenty of mathematicians hated that. In 2005 Georges Gonthier formalized a full proof in the Coq proof assistant, so now even the 'trust the program' part is machine-checked down to the logic. Which raises its own fun question about what we mean by understanding a proof.

Keep going